Last week we got the news – SmugMug buys Flickr. OK, now what?
SmugMug vs. Flickr
Before I get started, I want to disclose that I am an affiliate for SmugMug. I have no knowledge of the inner workings of SmugMug, but I do get paid if you decide to purchase an account with SmugMug based upon my recommendation (and you also save 15%). Since I’m disclosing all of that, here’s my SmugMug discount URL:
With that out of the way, let’s talk about this purchase.
Flickr and SmugMug are both online photo sharing sites, but they serve different markets and needs. Flickr is a social media site where you upload your photos to share, either on the service with other photographers or using links to post your photos elsewhere on the Internet.
SmugMug is a portfolio site and also a point of sale for photographers. This is where you create galleries of photos that you can share, either publicly or to a limited audience, and allow them to purchase your photos through the site. SmugMug integrates with Bay Photo for prints or allows you to sell digital downloads.
Flickr has a free version of the service supported by ads, but you can pay for an annual membership that provides more features and removes the ads for a relatively small fee.
SmugMug isn’t free, but it does offer a 14 free trial. Other than that, you pay to use the service. SmugMug also takes a 15% cut of your online photo sales.
Flickr Used to Be the Place for Photographers
That headline may upset some people who are still diehard fans of Flickr, but it’s safe to say that Flickr’s community diminished over the past few years. Different social media and photo sharing sites rose up to steal much of Flickr’s thunder, and Flickr did little to nothing to remain competitive.
Facebook is a horrible place to post your photos due to the aggressive compression applied to your images, but people post there anyway.
Because that’s where everyone else is these days. Not everyone has a Flickr account because it primarily appeals to photographers. However, nearly everyone has a Facebook account. So you put up with horrible compression in order to potentially reach a wider audience.
Another group of people embraced Instagram (which Facebook bought) for mostly the same reasons. With the rise of mobile phone photography, it was an easy and frictionless what to share photos in the moment.
Photographers who want to share their carefully composed and post-processed photos jump through hoops to get them on Instagram for much the same reason we post them on Facebook.
That’s where the people are.
The Social Media Backlash Created a New Awareness
Mark Zuckerberg’s two days of testimony before Congress opened a lot of eyes about the price we pay for using Facebook and Instagram as a “free” service.
These free social media sites are full of opportunities for us to reveal information about ourselves that Facebook and developers can mine to either sell us things or attempt to manipulate our opinions.
That sort of thing never happened on Flickr or SmugMug.
The problem is that we didn’t truly have an alternative that came to mind.
That all changed with the headline – SmugMug buys Flickr.
That’s because Flickr didn’t come to mind under the ownership of Yahoo or Verizon. Why?
Because both of those organizations are essentially advertising companies. They’re the other side of the same coin when compared to Facebook or Google services. They’re mining your data to exploit.
SmugMug doesn’t serve ads. Flickr does for free accounts, but it wasn’t mining your data to allow developers to exploit you.
SmugMug Buys Flickr – So What?
I think this purchase represents the potential for a turning point in social media, at least for photographers. The only thing that keeps me on Facebook are the groups, primarily with other photographers. I also belong to some Facebook groups that have nothing to do with photography.
Facebook groups are an easy choice for many organizers because it’s a free and easy way to provide a sense of community around their organization or business. They get a free tool to use in a place where most of their audience already exists.
To be honest, I’d love to see Facebook broken up and the part that supports groups split into its own entity. I’d pay money for a service like that so it wouldn’t have to mine my data.
Wait. Isn’t that what Flickr already does?
There are groups for almost everything on Flickr, and they’re open to both free and paid users. You can find a Flickr group for almost any photography topic. That could have gone the way of the Dodo bird under Verizon’s ownership, but I think it’s much safer in SmugMug’s hands.
That’s because the folks behind SmugMug are genuinely passionate about photography. I believe they will be good custodians of Flickr, even though they currently have no idea what changes may come in the future.
For the folks who use Flickr as a home for their photos – either to share or use as a backup – this is welcome news. For the folks who found true community on Flickr, it’s also good news.
Flickr May Have Appeal for Non-Photography Communities
There’s no rule that says your Flickr community has to be about photography.
Some of the groups I participate in using Facebook could just as easily have worked on Flickr. You need a group, you push a button. Next thing you know, you’re a group administrator.
If you have a training course and need a private group to chat with Students, Flickr would work as well as Facebook. Maybe better, because now we have people who absolutely don’t want to be on Facebook.
I don’t think this is what SmugMug has in mind for Flickr, but I can see it as a possibility. Facebook is ticking off it’s users, getting into political infighting, and censoring some of its users who have different opinions than those in Silicon Valley.
I don’t see this sort of thing on SmugMug or Flickr. It could be a new haven for those who feel oppressed on Facebook, YouTube or Google communities.
How Do Your Photos Look on Flickr or SmugMug?
Here’s how one of my photos look when shared from Flickr:
If you click on the photo, you’re taken to my account and the image hosted on Flickr.
While that isn’t something I want to use on my web site, I think it’s very useful for posting elsewhere. There are plenty of sharing options. Not only can you specify the size, as shown above, but there are links to social media platforms, html embed code and other methods of posting your photo online.
SmugMug also has a host of sharing options for your photos, and it allows full resolution display for your photos. Flickr uses compression, but it’s much better at it than Facebook.
The Biggest Benefit of SmugMug Buying Flickr
Suddenly, Flickr is legitimate again. It’s owned by people who care about photography and community. Just that simple change revitalized the potential for Flickr, even if it ends up morphing into some combination with SmugMug.
For now, both sharing sites will remain separate and continue operations as they are.
That gives those of us who left Flickr behind some time to get re-aquainted. After all, it’s a fantastic service with many benefits. The question is whether enough other users will come back to enjoy the service, or if it can appeal to a new generation.
I know my daughter doesn’t bother with Facebook anymore. In fact, she tells me that none of her friends really use Facebook. They’re on Instagram or Snapchat.
The way Snapchat is bleeding, I’ll be surprised if it’s still around next year.
So will Flickr appeal to a younger generation? That may depend upon adding new features, reading the market, and providing a service that the other photo sharing sites lack.
We’ll have to see if that happens.
Skylum Coupon Code
I mentioned at the start of the show that you can save 10% (or $10) on Skylum software, like Luminar and Aurora HDR using my coupon code. This is my affiliate code, which means that I make a small commission if you purchase from me, but it also means that you save money.
For Skylum products like Luminar and Aurora HDR, you save $10.
For other Skylum products, like the Creative Kit, you save 10%.
Just visit: https://williambeem.com/skylum
When you check out, use my Skylum coupon code: BEEM
Subscribe to The Photo Flunky Show
Thank you for listening to The Photo Flunky Show. Make sure you get every episode by subscribing.
iTunes – https://williambeem.com/itunes
Stitcher – https://williambeem.com/stitcher
Google Play – https://williambeem.com/googleplay
Blubrry – https://williambeem.com/blubrry